Read + Write + Report
Home | Start a blog | About Orble | FAQ | Blogs | Writers | Paid | My Orble | Login

Jumping the Shark

January 3rd 2007 01:30
The term Jump the Shark refers to the moment in which a TV show has lost its way; it is deemed to have passed its peak and moved away from its original premise. It typically is recognised as a single defining scene, although often it is broadened to include a general decline in the programme's quality rather than a single incident.
Fonzie (Henry Winkler) jumps the shark*


The term comes from a now infamous scene in the comedy Happy Days. It featured The Fonz literally jumping over a shark on water skis. It signified the moment for many viewers when they realised the show's plotlines had become illogical and there was no longer any point in tuning in.

The catalyst for the term entering pop culture was the website, jumptheshark.com, which came online in 1997. The site allows users to vote on and discuss the moments at which different shows jumped. There site has developed several categories, examples of which include:

Births
When a established character gives birth, usually because the actress is pregnant in real life. Similar to the New Character category.
Eg: Baby Dill, Rugrats

Deaths
Sometimes a conscious decision by the writers; often due to unfortunate circumstances. Similar to the departure category, but tends to be permanent (some exceptions, for example: Alias).

Eg: Tara, Buffy

Character Departures
Again sometimes a conscious decision by the writers; or due to a dispute with the actor. Usually done in a way that the character can return if need be.
Eg: Fox Mulder, The X-Files

Graduation
The kids grow up and graduate; thus the show ends up catering to a different demographic.
Eg: Riverdale High, Sabrina

Weddings
It's something that the show builds up over many seasons, but tends to be disappointing once it actually happens.
Eg: Lois and Clark, The New Adventures of Superman

The Movie
A successful series tends to spawn to the big screen. Often takes the show to places it cannot return from.
Eg: The plethora of movies based on Saturday Night Live sketches

New Character
Generally a tactic to try and bring in a new audience. Often happens after a Graduation.
Eg: Cousin Oliver, The Brady Bunch

Same Character, Different Actor
Usually a result of a death or dispute. If done well, hardly noticeable (such as Marilyn in The Munsters), however, it does tend to be very jarring for the audience.
Eg: The Two Darrens, Bewitched

Jump the Shark is now a popular vehicle for reference and parody, with shows such as the Simpsons, South Park and even Stargate SG-1 alluding to the concept.

So the question is, can a consensus generally be reached on the defining moment when a show jumps the shark? Or is it all just a matter of opinion? What are some examples of moments when you felt that a show jumped the shark?


*Screencap courtesy of Wikipedia, and used under Fair Dealing for identification and critical commentary.
Information courtesy of Wikipedia and jumptheshark.com
133
Vote
Add To: del.icio.us Digg Furl Spurl.net StumbleUpon Yahoo


   
subscribe to this blog 


   

   


Comments
25 Comments. [ Add A Comment ]

Comment by DuskDevi

January 3rd 2007 02:15
Hello Nina (pretty TV Babble-ina)...

COOLest post! Most Excellent.

Funny thing...individual matter of opinion seems to create a mass consensus as to when a TV series jumps the shark (um...did you get that cos I didn't!)... hence the reason many shows get pulled off.
If they were still getting an audience they would still be on air.

For my boys, Buffy jumped the vamp(!) when she did The Fang Thing with Spike...whereas I loved it!

When Jack left SG1...so did I.

'Desperate Housewives'...jumped the shark from the word go...

Hope you're well Ninabelle.

Dusk

Comment by KylieW

January 3rd 2007 03:08
Nina,

Great topic!! Love it. Here's a few I can think of...

1. Melrose Place - as soon as it fell into daytime soap storylines and the marcia cross character came back from the dead (can't even remember her name now). I couldn't watch the show after that.

2. Beverley Hill 90210 - I'm going to be generous and say it's when Dylan gets married and hitmen come after him and kill his new wife Toni instead of him. Really, hitmen after a 19 yr old? huh?? In truth, the show probably lost it long before this, but I still kind of watched it up until this point.

3. ER - Dr Greene's death.

4. Neighbours and Home and Away - from day one without a doubt.

5. The Practice - once Bobby and Lindsay got married. Though in the end it came back on track with James Spader.

And I totally agree with Dusk, I loved it when Buffy and Spike got together - Spike was so much more interesting than miserable, brooding Angel!

Okay, that's enough from me!

KylieW

Comment by DuskDevi

January 3rd 2007 03:24
...okay...I'm sick.
I'll get over it.

KW...remember that episode when Buffy and Spike literally tear the house down....hot!!!

This is sad but I do remember the JTS moments from these;
Dallas: when freakin' Bobby woke up.
Dynasty: when Krystal and Alexis had their slapfight, then brought out perfumes.

(Not that I watched these...)

Boston Legal - for some reason, they introduced some minor junior characters and it got jumpy but they're no longer part of the show and Denny, Alan and Shirley reign supreme.

Damn. I'm supposed to be prepping for features.
I'm outta here.

Probably be back....soon...

Comment by KylieW

January 3rd 2007 03:37
Oh yeah, I remember that scene with Buffy and Spike. Loved it. Nothing better than a huge fight that turns into hot dangerous sex. Very hot!!

Boston Legal is one of the most quirky shows on tv. I definitely think it's better now that they've weeded a lot of characters out. I could just watch Denny, Alan and Shirley all day.

Comment by Nina

January 3rd 2007 10:13
DuskDevi and KylieW: Thanks for those Jump the Shark moments. An interesting fact - despite the Happy Days episode I mentioned being the defining Jump the Shark moment, the show continued for another 100 episodes after that. It's interesting that, even when there is a consensus about when the show takes the leap, it can still stick around.

I too was a big fan of Buffy and Spike together - I never really took to Angel. The scene where they demolished the house just about lit my screen on fire! Definitely not a Jump the Shark moment for me; quite the opposite in fact. I wonder if there is a term for that? If there isn't, there should be...

Comment by postmoderncritic

January 3rd 2007 23:17
Thanks for the background info on "jumping the shark," it's good to know where it came from! )

Spuffy was fine with me, though I am proudly vanilla. For me Buffy 'jumped the shark' when it didn't continue to celebrate its fantasy genre by deconstructing it some more after the fabulous 'Normal Again'.

Comment by Ash

January 3rd 2007 23:30
Hi Nina
Had to laugh at some of these! I think the one "jumping the shark' scene that i can think of was from "Las Vegas". Forgive me as i don`t really know any of the character names but up until this point it was an ok series to watch. Then they had a scene of one of the main actresses standing on a roof top and having an argument with one of her employees. She lifted up her arms and the material of her dress was a bit droopy. A gust of wind sent her shooting off the top of the building, across town and into a shoe store....it was just one of those scenes when you think, "Nah that`s it for me!"
Ash

Comment by Nina

January 4th 2007 00:11
postmoderncritic: Jump the Shark is such an interesting term, so I'm glad that I could enlighten you as to it's origins. When I first found out it came from a literal shark jumping, I could scarcely believe it!
I do think Buffy lost its way somewhat when it stopped examining its genre and opted for more traditional and straightforward storylines, although I admit that I did enjoy some episodes after that point.

Comment by Nina

January 4th 2007 00:15
Ash: I would occasionally switch over to Las Vegas if there was nothing else on, and I happened to turn it on just as that scene happened. I have to say, my reaction was the same as yours. Not being a regular viewer, I'm not sure if that scene was in the vein of the show or not, but it seemed like a jump the shark moment to me!

Comment by postmoderncritic

January 4th 2007 00:16
I must admit that Conversations With Dead People was magnificent, and there were some very fine moments here and there after NA. By the time season 6 was winding up I'd had also had enough of the non-stop depression-a-thon.

Comment by Ash

January 4th 2007 00:23
Yep I never watched the show too often, but when i did it seemed your regular, run of the mill show....until that! That was certainly WAY out of the ordinary..I suppose in Las Vegas anything is possible though and they were just keeping in line with that *smile*

Comment by Nina

January 4th 2007 00:31
postmoderncritic: I'd actually forgotten about Conversations With Dead People; that indeed was a good episode. The whole series did get very melancholy; I really missed the light-hearted and often self-referential humour of the earlier seasons.

Ash: Well they say what happens in Vegas stays in Vegas, so lets hope bizarre television moments like that stay there too!

Comment by Andrea

January 4th 2007 01:09
Hi Nina

I'll admit, I jumped over the SG1 shark when Daniel Jackson left ... however, I returned when he returned. The character they replaced him with just didn't cut the mustard for me.

I stayed with SG1, even when Jack left, then again, that could have something to do with his replacement being hot !!!

I love Stargate SG1.

I'll also agree with Dusk on the Desperate Housewives point ... jumped from episode 1, definitely.

A.H.

Comment by Nina

January 4th 2007 01:33
Andrea: Whether the departure of a character is a jump the shark moment really depends on the character and how their departure is dealt with. A hot replacement certainly can ease the pain!

Comment by pegasus

January 4th 2007 02:52
It is disappointing when a show 'jumps the shark' but it would be hard for a show's writers to come up with fresh, top-rate material year after year. There comes a point when the characters have done everything appropriate for that character, and then what? Bring out the shark tank, waterskis, and enjoy the ride down, baby.

Comment by Nina

January 4th 2007 02:54
pegasus: That's an interesting point - is it better for a show to retire while it is still in its prime, or go on to shark-jumping moments in the hope that the show will stay alive?

Comment by pegasus

January 4th 2007 03:02
If any money can be made, the show's producers will push on regardless, unforturnately.

Maybe Jerry Seinfeld got it right by taking Seinfeld off the air by choice and while they were still making great episodes.

Although, the series finale wasn't great: Jerry and the gang get locked up for not being Good Samaritans. Maybe what was supposed to be the Grand Finale swan song, turned out to be a shark-jump!?

Comment by DuskDevi

January 4th 2007 07:52
Oh cripes...I must remember to 'Yes' for replies...

Thought my Buffy Spike (something-that-rhymes-with- 'jump' -and-is-rather-crass-in-this-context-starts- with) huh?...the shark -comment put y'all off...

...to find that you Ninabelle and you KW are just as sick as mwah mwah Moi!

A classic example of a show retiring in it's prime is 'Family Ties' .
sigh...The Keatons...and Courtney Cox....

Hmm...Ninabelle...did you watch 'Friends'?
When do you think the JTS moment was for this?

Comment by Nina

January 4th 2007 08:11
DuskDevi: There certainly does seem to be a core of Spike and Buffy lovers here!
I'm afraid I didn't watch Friends... it was just one of those shows that I never ended up tuning in to.

Comment by Vimal

January 4th 2007 21:56
Wow Nina, thx for the info. So now if someone uses the term "jump the shark" I know what it means instead of feeling like a shark out of the water lol.

Comment by Nina

January 4th 2007 22:57
pegasus: Sorry, I missed you second comment yesterday. I too felt the finale of Seinfeld was a real let down. A lot of people agree with us - 'the finale' received the second-most votes on jumptheshark.com (although the most votes is for 'never jumped')

Vimal: I'm glad I was able to inform you about this rather strange term!

Comment by signals

January 5th 2007 01:12
It is an opinion.PERIOD! Ted Mcginey may be the poster child but Married...with children beat the odds for him. I thought Drew Carey jumped when Oswald got breast, but others found the boring show worthy of continuing for years.

Great entry! I liked it.

Comment by Nina

January 5th 2007 03:01
signals: Thanks for stopping by. It certainly is down to opinion, although occasionally a moment will come along which almost everyone can appreciate as being JTS worthy.

Comment by Cibbuano

January 9th 2007 01:57
I love the idea of identifying the 'jump the shark' moment. Because we've all seen it happen, and it's almost a mark of shame.

are there shows that never jumped? I would argue Seinfeld...

Comment by Nina

January 9th 2007 07:30
Cibbuano: There are definitely shows that never jumped - jumptheshark.com has a section that encompasses those shows. It lists programmes such as Fawlty Towers and The Simpsons - but of course, not everyone agrees.

Personally, I think Seinfeld never jumped, even if the last episode was quite weak. I also think that Futurama never jumped.

Add A Comment

To create a fully formatted comment please click here.


CLICK HERE TO LOGIN | CLICK HERE TO REGISTER

Name or Orble Tag
Home Page (optional)
Comments
Bold Italic Underline Strikethrough Separator Left Center Right Separator Quote Insert Link Insert Email
Notify me of replies
Notify extra people about this comment
Is this a private comment?
List the Email Addresses or Orble Tags of the people you would like to be notified about this comment


One per line max of 30

List the Email Addresses or Orble Tags of the people you would like to be notified about this private comment thread. Only the people in this list will be able to see or reply to your comment.


One per line max of 30

Your Name
(for the email going out to the above list, it can be different to your Orble Tag)
Your Email Address
(optional)
(required for reply notification)
Submit
More Posts
4 Posts
3 Posts
1 Posts
182 Posts dating from September 2006
Email Subscription
Receive e-mail notifications of new posts on this blog:
0

Jolie Roberson's Blogs

I have no other blogs :(
Moderated by Jolie Roberson
Copyright © 2006 2007 2008 On Topic Media PTY LTD. All Rights Reserved. Design by Vimu.com.
On Topic Media ZPages: Sydney |  Melbourne |  Brisbane |  London |  Birmingham |  Leeds     [ Advertise ] [ Contact Us ] [ Privacy Policy ]